Paternalism and respect for autonomy essay

paternalism and autonomy conflict

This is not an irrational refusal of the surgery. The idea that individual patients should have the freedom to make choices about their lives, including medical matters, has become increasingly prominent in current literature.

doctor knows best paternalism

The perception is that there is a need to advance a larger social good -- for example, to protect the community from patients with communicable diseases or from psychiatric patients who are a danger to others. MP Private providers keep family medicine electronic records and some family physicians are worried that the commitment to confidentiality may thus be questionable.

Medical paternalism examples

Great effort has been undertaken to protect data personal health information , but this protection is not consistently applied on all levels. If decisions we make now are likely to be regretted in the future and are more likely to be irreversible, paternalistic intervention is there to step in and aid the decision. This situation is a justified situation for paternalism to step in. Shelton Eds. Why or why not? Croatia, as a transitional country, is currently undergoing this particular process. Principles of biomedical ethics. Many approached physicians, however, because of their conflicting schedules had to decline participation. That person will eventually regret this decision because they will find it hard to get a job with limited education, and also find it virtually impossible to put themselves back through school with limited funds to do so.

Family practitioners were especially concerned about this problem since they issue these certificates. Tugging in another direction are concerns about the premature loss of a life.

Medical paternalism and patient autonomy

The right timing here is very important. Abstract Background Patient autonomy is a fundamental, yet challenging, principle of professional medical ethics. For example, to obtain coverage from the national insurance fund, patient-identifying data, such as their names and diagnoses, have to be sent to a central office. MP Nevertheless, it is important to note here that the literature reveals preferences of patients to generally be informed [ 19 , 20 ]. The purpose of autonomy is to allow us to choose to do things that affect only ourselves and does not negatively affect those around us. Methods A qualitative research was conducted by means of six focus group discussions held in and in Croatia. And I had great difficulties to keep that, just technically speaking… because in our community and mentality it is normal that the doorkeeper has the list of all the names and directs the visitors. Added to that is the inherent uncertainty of medicine, and the occasional medical miracle more frequent in the TV depiction of medicine. In these societies it is usually not the physician and patient that form the core decision-making unit.

But we might be inclined to see that as an inappropriate value when doctors treat their patients as if they were imprudent and ignorant children, incapable of making good decisions about how their lives ought to go.

However, further research should be conducted in order to understand how these attitudes are related to the collapse of authoritarian regimes. All the students who were given the option to participate consented since the group was held during their medical ethics seminar class.

An assistant moderator GP also took notes and handled logistics. I think that now we have to slowly change that and give individual autonomy a higher [place in the] hierarchy of values than before.

Paternalism in healthcare example

Again, to make certain that this is real in your mind, I want you to consider the case of Rita M. I was lying there for days feeling really sick and miserable. On the spectrum of differing levels of independence, paternalism stands on the opposite side of autonomy. For such a model to function effectively, the following elements are essential: the maintenance of trust in the physician-patient relationship; respect; and the adoption of patient-centered communication [ 31 , 40 ]. That is, you are the patient in this case. A third response to our original question might go like this: "A good doctor will be very reluctant to acquiesce to patient refusals of recommended treatment. Dordrecht: Kluwer. Shelton Eds. The advantages of having paternalism in place is that in the long run, with paternalistic intervention, our decisions will be better made. Physicians, they said, have to be skilled, educated and aware of how to disclose the truth. The word calls to mind the image of a father "pater" in Latin who makes decisions for his children rather than letting them make their own decisions, on the grounds that "father knows best. However, further research should be conducted in order to understand how these attitudes are related to the collapse of authoritarian regimes. Altogether, 56 voluntary participants took part in this study and all of them read and signed the provided consent form after the main researcher explained the research. She knows there is a risk of blood clots forming from the surgery, that these could result in her suffering a stroke that would leave her with cognitive deficits for the rest of her life, deficits that might reduce substantially the quality of her life. An assistant moderator GP also took notes and handled logistics.
Rated 10/10 based on 110 review
Autonomy vs. Paternalism Essays